BiDi SFP vs duplex: which one to choose
BiDi or duplex? How a BiDi transceiver works over a single fiber, when it actually pays off, when duplex is the smarter call, and the mistakes to avoid.
You need to connect two racks, two buildings or two sites, and there's only one spare fiber. Or you do have two, and someone says "just use BiDi, saves a fiber". This article explains how a BiDi transceiver works, when it genuinely helps, when plain duplex is the better choice, and the three mistakes we see most often in the field.
How duplex works
A regular duplexDuplex Verbindung über zwei Fasern: eine zum Senden, eine zum Empfangen. Der Standard für die meisten SFP- und QSFP-Optiken mit LC-Duplex-Stecker. optic uses two fibers: one to transmit, one to receive. The TX on one end goes to the RX on the other, and vice versa. Both ends transmit on the same wavelength; 1000BASE-LX and 10GBASE-LR, for example, both transmit at 1310 nm.
That makes duplex pleasantly boring. Both ends take exactly the same module, you order one part number, and your spare fits either side. The connector is usually LC duplex, and the patch cords are ordinary duplex patch cords.
How BiDi works
A BiDiBiDi Bidirektionaler Transceiver: sendet und empfängt über eine einzige Faser auf zwei verschiedenen Wellenlängen (zum Beispiel 1310/1550 nm). Er wird immer paarweise mit gespiegelten Wellenlängen eingesetzt. optic transmits and receives over one and the same fiber. That works because each direction uses its own wavelength. Inside the module, a WDM filter separates the outgoing light on one wavelength from the incoming light on the other.
Two examples from the standards:
- 1G — 1000BASE-BX10 (IEEE 802.3, clause 59) transmits at 1310 nm on one end and 1490 nm on the other, over a single single-mode fiber up to 10 km.
- 10G — the BiDi PHYs in IEEE 802.3cp use 1270 and 1330 nm.
The consequence: the two ends are not identical. With BX10, one module transmits at 1310 and receives at 1490, the other does the opposite. Modules for longer reaches often use a different pair, but the principle stays the same: the two ends mirror each other. So you always order BiDi as a pair, a U and a D version. How those pairs work, and what BX10, BX20 and BX40 actually mean, gets its own article.
When BiDi is the right call
BiDi is about fiber count, not speed or quality. A BiDi link isn't faster or better than a duplex link; it just uses half the fibers. That matters when fiber is scarce or expensive:
- You lease dark fiber per strand — BiDi needs one strand per link instead of two.
- Your cable or ODF is full — on an existing campus run or a packed patch panel, BiDi doubles the number of links without pulling new cable.
- One fiber of a pair is broken — BiDi lets you run over the strand that still works.
When duplex is smarter
In the data center, within a row or between two racks, you usually have plenty of fiber and your patch cords are duplex already. BiDi gains you nothing there, but it does cost you:
- Two part numbers instead of one — your spares stock doubles: for every reach and every coding you need both a U and a D.
- More room for ordering mistakes — ordering the same half twice is the classic BiDi error. With duplex it can't happen.
- Multimode for short runs — for short links within the rack or row, multimode duplex (SR) is the normal choice.
Our take: don't buy BiDi for a link where you simply have two fibers. You gain nothing, and at 4 pm with a dead link you don't want to be wondering which half was on this end.
Three mistakes we see a lot
- The same half twice — two U modules or two D modules won't link. They transmit on the same wavelength and both listen for a wavelength nobody is sending.
- BiDi on one end, duplex on the other — doesn't work. Different wavelengths, different number of fibers.
- Reading "BiDi" as "one fiber" at 40G multimode — on some 40G modules, such as 40G SR-BD, BiDi means something else: two wavelengths per fiber, but still over a duplex multimode connection. At higher speeds, always read the datasheet.
Also mind the reach figure. "20 km" means the module is specified for a link of that class, not that every 20 km link will work. Do the power budget maths, connectors and splices included.
What to do next
Count your fibers first. If you have two per link and no reason to economise, go with regular duplex optics: 1G SFP or 10G SFP+. If fiber is scarce, go BiDi and always order in pairs: 1G BiDi or 10G BiDi. We supply the SFP-1G BiDi in 20, 40 and 80 km versions, with an LC simplex connector and coded for your platform. Note that the 80 km version uses a different wavelength pair than the 20 and 40 km ones.
Not sure which end should be U and which D, or whether your link fits the power budget? Call an engineer and we'll work it out with you.

Gründer von FiberNxt und Xyphen IT
Yvan Watchman ist Gründer von FiberNxt und Xyphen IT. Er baut und betreibt seit Jahren Netzwerke und Rechenzentrumsinfrastruktur in und um Amsterdam.
Passende Produkte und Dienstleistungen
Häufig gestellte Fragen
Can I connect a BiDi transceiver to a regular duplex optic?
No. A duplex optic transmits and receives on the same wavelength over two fibers; a BiDi transmits and receives on two different wavelengths over one fiber. Both ends of a BiDi link have to be BiDi, and they have to be the two mirrored halves of a pair.
Is a BiDi link slower than a duplex link?
No. A 1G BiDi runs at 1 Gb/s and a 10G BiDi at 10 Gb/s, same as the duplex version. The only difference is how many fibers the link uses.
Which patch cord do I need for a BiDi SFP?
A simplex single-mode patch cord: one fiber, with the connector that matches the module. Most BiDi SFPs use a simplex LC, but SC versions exist too. All our BiDi modules have an LC simplex connector. Check your patch panel as well before you order cables.