Optics

BiDi SFP pairs explained: U/D, 1310/1490, BX10/20/40 and why you always buy two

Two BiDi optics in and no link? What U and D, 1310/1490, 1270/1330 and BX10/20/40 mean, what the standard actually says, plus an ordering checklist.

5 min readBy Yvan Watchman

You ordered two BiDi optics, plugged them into the switches, connected the fiber, and there's no link. Odds are you have the same half twice. This article explains what U and D, 1310/1490 and 1270/1330 mean, what BX10, BX20 and BX40 do and don't tell you, and gives you a checklist to order a correct pair the first time.

Why it's always a pair

A BiDi transceiver transmits and receives over a single fiber, on two different wavelengths. One end transmits on wavelength A and listens on B; the other transmits on B and listens on A. Two identical modules therefore transmit on the same wavelength and both wait for light nobody sends. No link, even if the port LED happens to be on.

That's why every BiDi comes in two versions, and each link needs one of each. If you want to revisit when BiDi makes sense in the first place, read BiDi SFP vs duplex.

U and D: upstream and downstream

The letters come from the standard. IEEE 802.3 defines 1000BASE-BX10 (clause 59) for access networks: the D module (downstream) sits at the central side, the U module (upstream) at the subscriber side.

For 1G that means:

  • 1000BASE-BX10-D — transmits at 1490 nm, receives at 1310 nm.
  • 1000BASE-BX10-U — transmits at 1310 nm, receives at 1490 nm.

In a data center or on a campus there's no "subscriber" or "central office", so which end is U doesn't matter technically. Agree on it once though, say D always on the core side. Then you know which spare to grab when something fails.

BX10 is the standard, BX20/40/80 are not

This is where the confusion starts. For 1G point-to-point BiDi, IEEE 802.3 only defines BX10: one single-mode fiber, up to 10 km. Modules labelled BX20, BX40 or BX80 are a vendor convention on top of that. They have a stronger laser or a more sensitive receiver, so they can bridge a longer link.

Because it isn't a standard, wavelengths vary by vendor, especially at longer reaches. For 80 km, many modules move to 1490/1550 nm (sometimes 1510/1570). The reason: single-mode fiber attenuates less at 1550 nm than at 1310 nm. A G.652.D cable, for example, is specified at a maximum of 0.40 dB/km at 1310 nm and 0.30 dB/km at 1550 nm. Over 80 km that adds up to 8 dB.

Our SFP-1G BiDi works the same way:

  • BX20 and BX40 — U transmits at 1310 nm and receives at 1490 nm; D does the reverse.
  • BX80 — U transmits at 1490 nm and receives at 1550 nm; D transmits at 1550 nm and receives at 1490 nm.

So the rule doesn't change: the two ends mirror each other. But a BX80-U won't work with a BX20-D or BX40-D, because those use a different pair. If you mix modules from different sources, always check the wavelengths on the datasheet, not just the "BX40" label.

10G: 1270/1330

For 10G, 1270/1330 nm is the common pair. Since 2021 it's in IEEE 802.3cp as 10GBASE-BR10, -BR20 and -BR40: the D side transmits at 1330 nm, the U side at 1270 nm. Commercially they're often still sold as "BX", for example SFP-10G-BX20-U and -D. Anything beyond 40 km, such as 60 or 80 km, is again a vendor extension outside the standard.

Our SFP-10G BiDi follows that split in the 20 and 40 km versions: the D version transmits at 1330 nm, the U version at 1270 nm. The 80 km version, as with 1G, uses the 1490/1550 pair: U transmits at 1490 nm, D at 1550 nm. All our BiDi modules have an LC simplex connector.

More reach isn't always better

An 80 km module on a short link can overload the receiver at the far end. One 1000BASE-BX80 datasheet, for example, lists transmit power up to +5 dBm, a receiver overload limit of −3 dBm and a power budget of 8 to 26 dB. So the link needs at least 8 dB of loss; a short patch won't get you there. You'd need an attenuator, or simply a module with less reach. Pick the reach that fits your power budget, not the biggest one on offer.

Checklist: ordering a correct BiDi pair

  • Measure or calculate the length and loss of your link, connectors and splices included.
  • Choose the reach that fits that power budget, not automatically the longest.
  • Decide per link which end is U and which is D, following one fixed convention.
  • Check the wavelengths of both modules for that reach: transmit on A and receive on B, and exactly the reverse. An 80 km pair often uses different wavelengths than a 20 or 40 km pair.
  • Pick the coding for the switch each end goes into; it can differ per end.
  • Check the connector (our BiDi modules are LC simplex) and order a matching simplex single-mode patch cord.
  • Order spares as a pair: one U and one D per type, reach and coding.

What to do next

Run your existing BiDi links past the checklist, especially if you mix modules from different vendors. Then order in pairs: 1G BiDi or 10G BiDi, with your platform's coding on each end. Unsure about the reach, or the wavelengths at the far end? Call an engineer and we'll take a look with you.

Yvan Watchman

About the author

Yvan Watchman

Founder of FiberNxt and Xyphen IT

Yvan Watchman is the founder of FiberNxt and Xyphen IT. He has been building and running networks and data centre infrastructure in and around Amsterdam for years.

LinkedIn profile

Related products and services

Frequently asked questions

What does "1310nm TX/1490nm RX" mean exactly?

The module transmits at 1310 nm and receives at 1490 nm. For 1G BiDi that's the U side. The module at the far end has to be the exact mirror: transmit at 1490 nm, receive at 1310 nm. That's the D side.

Can I pair a BX20-U with a BX40-D?

Sometimes it works, if the wavelengths are mirrored and the power levels fall within each other's range. With an 80 km module it often can't work at all, because it uses a different wavelength pair. That varies by vendor and by module. We advise against it: order both ends with the same reach, the same wavelengths and from the same series.

Which end should be U and which D in my own network?

Technically it doesn't matter, as long as the two ends are mirrored. The standard puts D at the central side (the OLT, in access networks) and U at the subscriber side. Pick a fixed convention yourself, such as D on the core side, and stick to it everywhere. It makes spares much simpler.

Further reading