Optics

Choosing 400G: QSFP-DD or OSFP, and which optic?

Planning a 400G spine/leaf or DCI upgrade? How to choose between QSFP-DD and OSFP and between SR8, DR4, XDR4, FR4, LR4 and ZR, with breakout, power and FEC.

5 min readBy Yvan Watchman

You're planning a 400G upgrade of your spine/leaf, or a DCI link between two data centers, and the decisions pile up: QSFP-DD or OSFP, SR8 or DR4, FR4 or LR4, and where does ZR fit in? This article explains how the two form factors differ, which optic goes with which distance and which cabling, what you can and can't break out, and how to migrate from 100G without replacing everything at once.

QSFP-DD or OSFP: the same 400G in a different housing

Electrically, both form factors do the same job: eight lanes of 50G using PAM4, 400G in total. The difference is mechanical.

  • QSFP-DD — "double density": a QSFP housing with a second row of contacts, 76 pins instead of 38. The MSA keeps the cage backward compatible with QSFP+ and QSFP28, so your 100G optics fit a 400G port without an adapter. Not the other way round.
  • OSFP — wider, usually with the heatsink built into the module itself. That gives it more thermal headroom, but a QSFP28 won't go in without an adapter, and your platform has to support that adapter.

The form factor comes with the switch. If you want to reuse your 100G optics during the migration, pick a QSFP-DD platform.

Which optic for which distance

OpticDefined byReachConnectorBreakout
400GBASE-SR8IEEE 802.3cm, Clause 138100 m OM4MPO-162× 200G or 8× 50G
400GBASE-DR4IEEE 802.3bs, Clause 124500 mMPO-12 APC4× 100G-DR
400G-XDR4 (DR4+)vendors, not IEEE2 kmMPO-12 APC4× 100G-FR1
400GBASE-FR4IEEE 802.3cu, Clause 1512 kmduplex LCnone
400G-LR4100G Lambda MSA (IEEE: 6 km)10 kmduplex LCnone
400ZR / ZR+OIF 400ZR, OpenZR+up to 120 km amplifiedduplex LCnone (ZR+: 4× 100GE multiplexed onto one wavelength)

DR4 and XDR4 send four parallel 100G lanes over eight fibres. FR4 and LR4 put four wavelengths on a single fibre pair. So parallel optics need MPO trunks, while FR4 and LR4 run over plain duplex LC; see MPO vs LC for polarity, polish and cassettes.

Read the label on LR4 carefully. IEEE defines 400GBASE-LR4-6 for 6 km, while the 100G Lambda MSA's LR4-10 reaches 10 km on the same grid. Use the same type at both ends.

400ZR is a different animal: coherent optics using DP-16QAM on a single DWDM channel. The OIF spec covers amplified links up to 120 km, or unamplified links with an 11 dB loss budget (in practice about 35 to 45 km). ZR+ goes further over amplified networks. That's DCI territory, with a mux and a channel plan.

Breakout: what splits and what doesn't

Breakout is why so many designs end up on DR4. One DR4 on the spine feeds four leaf ports with 100G-DR1 optics over an MPO-to-LC breakout. For 2 km, XDR4 does the same with four FR1s. How those single-lambda 100G optics work is covered in choosing 100G single-mode optics.

FR4 and LR4 can't be broken out: the four wavelengths are combined and split inside the module. And a 100G-LR4 or CWDM4 won't talk to a DR4 or XDR4 breakout lane: 4× 25G NRZ versus 1× 100G PAM4, even if the reach matches.

Power, heat, CMIS and FEC

A 100G QSFP28 draws about 2.5 to 4.5 W, depending on type. 400G SR8, DR4, FR4 and LR4 modules are rated at up to about 10 to 12 W in datasheets. Coherent ZR and ZR+ modules go up to about 20 W, more for high-output ZR+. With 32 ports per switch, that adds up fast in your cooling.

Both MSAs use the same power classes: class 7 up to 14 W, class 8 above that. A module starts in low-power mode; the switch reads the power class first and only then powers it up fully. So check which class your switch allows per port, especially for ZR.

That readout goes through CMIS, the management interface for QSFP-DD and OSFP. QSFP28 uses SFF-8636. For third-party optics, that means the coding lives in a different memory map; see third-party optics and coding.

On top of that, every 400GBASE-R link runs RS(544,514) FEC, always on and handled by the host. How it works and what it costs in latency is in FEC explained.

From 100G to 400G without replacing everything

  • List the distance, fibre type and existing cabling for each link: MPO or duplex LC.
  • Choose a spine platform with QSFP-DD if you want to reuse 100G optics during the transition.
  • Pick DR1 or FR1 for new or replacement 100G optics towards your leafs, so they fit a 400G breakout later.
  • Choose DR4 or XDR4 for breakout, FR4 or LR4 for point-to-point 400G over existing duplex fibre.
  • Work out the power budget for each link, including MPO connectors and cassettes.
  • Check the supported power class, breakout modes and FEC settings per port, at both ends.

We'll think along with your design

400G optics, MPO cabling and breakout cables are deliberately not in the webshop: form factor, cabling, breakout plan and power per port all have to fit together, and you'd rather find a mistake on paper than in a maintenance window.

Send us your switches, distances, what's already installed and how many ports you'll need in two years. We'll review it with you, work out the links and send you a quote. Request a quote from an engineer, or have a look at our services if you want the links tested and documented after installation. The 100G optics for your leafs, such as DR1, you can order straight from 100G QSFP28.

Yvan Watchman

About the author

Yvan Watchman

Founder of FiberNxt and Xyphen IT

Yvan Watchman is the founder of FiberNxt and Xyphen IT. He has been building and running networks and data centre infrastructure in and around Amsterdam for years.

LinkedIn profile

Related products and services

Frequently asked questions

Does a QSFP28 optic fit a QSFP-DD port?

Yes. The MSA requires the QSFP-DD cage to stay backward compatible with QSFP+ and QSFP28, with no adapter. Not the other way round: a QSFP-DD module won't fit a QSFP28 port. Whether your switch then runs that port at 100G is up to the platform, so check your vendor's compatibility matrix.

Can I break out a 400G-FR4 into four 100G links?

No. FR4 puts four wavelengths on one duplex pair and splits them inside the module. For breakout you need a parallel module: DR4 for 4× 100G-DR up to 500 m, or XDR4 (also sold as DR4+) for 4× 100G-FR1 up to 2 km.

Why aren't 400G optics in the webshop?

Because the right choice depends on your form factor, your cabling, your breakout plan and how much power and cooling your switch offers per port. We'd rather look at your design first and then send you a quote that fits.

Further reading